Five Justices Deliver Illegal Ruling, Declaring Constitutional Litigation Act Amendment Invalid

Five grand justices—Hsu Tzung-li, Hsieh Ming-yang, Tsai Tsai-chen, Chen Chung-wu, and Yu Po-hsiang—issued the 2025 Constitutional Judgment No. 1 while failing to meet the legal quorum for deliberation, declaring the amendment to the 'Constitutional Litigation Act' passed by the Legislative Yuan unconstitutional. This move sparked major controversy over 'destroying the constitution and disturbing administration,' while three other justices issued dissenting opinions stating the judgment was invalid.